The variables for the volume of a tumor, as measured by a caliper, are determined by a, b, and c in Figure 1, where length L is 2a, width W is 2b, and height H is c. VT, the volume of a tumor is determined by. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. The PubMed wordmark and PubMed logo are registered trademarks of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). In caliper measurements, two values, for length and width, must be recorded for one tumor in each animal; this means that for every 100 animals studied, at least 200 measurements must be made and recorded. Before Because the industrys caliper-based formula allows for these inclusions in nonexistent volumes more often than not, it yields inaccurate measurements, which can confuse. Biol. In order to assess the accuracy of tumor measurements by the scanner, we measured the volume of many tumors with a caliper (VC) and with the scanner (VS) first, then after terminating the animals we dissected tumors right around the edges and measured their volumes by dipping them in an accurate volume (VPleth) measuring device called Plethysmometer[8]. Figure 4. Tumor volume in subcutaneous mouse xenografts measured by microCT is more accurate and reproducible than determined by 18 F-FDG-microPET or external caliper. Using a caliper, growth of the tumor in height is not measured as only width and length changes will affect the calculated volume. The last step is to find the f constant of the two-dimensional mathematical model for tumor growth without therapy (Phase I). Bizberg Themes, By Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center. Similar to the results from the experiments in Figure 18., this error makes the drug seem less effective than it actually is. Several studies have investigated the effectiveness of bevacizumab therapy according to different cancer types but these days there is an intense debate on its utility. The tumor shown has a dip in its form, which means that its volume will be less than that of a tumor without a dip. A caliper measurement would only take into account the components for length and width and therefore ignore this dip measured by the values for height, which would, in turn, inaccurately measure the tumors volume. [2]no matter how accurately the length and width of the tumor are measured. . In this phase, three groups were created. To compare more than two samples, ANOVA test was applied. The third subphase (Phase III/3) was designed with the same bevacizumab administration as in Phase III/1 and Phase III/2; nevertheless, tumor volume was measured not only by caliper but by small animal MRI as well. Since, the assumptions made to measure a 3D object with 2D measurements, the error due to the geometrical assumption are larger than the errors due to handling of the animal causing deformation of the tumor, and this aspect, in general, is ignored. [45] have found that the combination of low-dose cyclophosphamide and ginsenoside Rg3 therapy can be more effective than the normal administration. Open Access articles citing this article. The second subphase (Phase III/2) was similar to Phase III/1, mice received the same dosage of bevacizumab as in Phase III/1, however sample size was higher (6 immunocompetent mice in control group, 12 immunocompetent mice in case group), and bevacizumab administration started earlier, on the 3rd day of the experiment. Statistical evaluations of agreement between two methods for measuring a quantitative variable. to calculate several estimates of tumor volume using the equations for the volume of a sphere ([4 /3]r3), Here r is average of a, b and c the volume of an tumor height has to be approximated. produced by the TumorImager-2TM so that the animal is aligned under the mask each time similarly to the previous scan. Mice were monitored daily by personnel experienced in recognizing signs of morbidity (illness, injury, or abnormal behavior) also in weekends and holidays. Yes To reduce the time of analysis one could e.g. Thus, caliper-based measurements are less accurate the more the height of the stack deviates from its width. No, Is the Subject Area "Mouse models" applicable to this article? The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the Treat. Further geometrical or visual data are not stored simultaneously. However mice which were treated with a quasi-continuous therapy (one-tenth dose of control dose spread over 18 days, i.e. Cancer Res. Am. One common measure of efficacy is the T/C ratio, the ratio of tumor volume in control versus treated mice at a specified Folia Biol. Furthermore, caliper-based measurements cause undue stress on the animal and, by extension, the tumor, which can further distort measurements. bowel, and kidneys is when the tumor is located in . To obtain Later in a study, when a tumor grows into larger masses, the shape of the tumor can differ greatly from an ellipsoid, as shown in Figure 7. Figure 15. Contrast agents improve the visibility, but it is an extra strain to the organism, which can be lethal to animals which are in the final stage of cancer. CAS Most, if not all, tumors do not fit into this category; this discrepancy results in caliper-based volume measurements including sections that do not exist in the actual tumor, or an overestimation of tumor volume measurement. 37, 331337 (2011). A smaller diameter mask will help to position the tumor in the center of the scan, but it will not alter this effect. r>12TzPn 4x PUj50"pJ{{>y{.mn|Cvz{PP5x kH:5:YM.gn?c[J8oQWkR_!X/C@6P@WT=gO5Sn>om}&SI cyT>E"TnkhSju>~yVOm^C~0__ww@ y[xQr33?6O~hZcR{{u]=O5T. VC refers to tumor volume values calculated through the formula VT = 0.5 L W2, and VCH refers to those through the formula VT = 0.5 L W H. VS refers to measurements taken by the scanner, and % Inc. refers to the percent increase between VS and VCH. These images also provide extra morphological information about the tumor growth and the effect of the compounds on tumor behavior. Mammary tumors similar to those observed in women can be induced in rats by intraperitoneal administration of N-methyl-N-nitrosourea. Eichelerger, L.E. One can find datasets in Table 3. . Clinical criteria that establish when the endpoint have to be carried out: a) if tumors contributed to a gain of >20% in body weight compared to controls at the same time point; b) tumors that ulcerate, become necrotic or infected; c) any animal found unexpectedly to be moribund, cachectic, or unable to obtain food or water. Finally, it finds the volume between these two surfaces and sets this to be the volume of the tumor (shaded red region in Figure 11, red region in Figure 14 below). Tumor cells form and expand subcutaneously in the cavity they are injected, into between the layers of the skin. Clipboard, Search History, and several other advanced features are temporarily unavailable. Breast Cancer Res. All mice were implanted with HT-29 human colorectal adenocarcinoma. HHS Vulnerability Disclosure, Help The caliper, unlike the scanner, does not consider that the height of the stack changes while the length and width remain the same. No, PLOS is a nonprofit 501(c)(3) corporation, #C2354500, based in San Francisco, California, US, Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions, https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0142190, http://www.gene.com/download/pdf/avastin_prescribing.pdf, http://www.ema.europa.eu/docs/en_GB/document_library/EPAR_-_Scientific_Discussion/human/000582/WC500029262.pdf, http://www.protocol-online.org/prot/Protocols/Xenograft-Tumor-Model-Protocol-3810.html, http://www.targeson.com/sites/default/files/content/pages/pdfs/tail_vein_protocol_2012_0.pdf. The tumor burden is evaluated by volume calculation using caliper measurement. Measure the mass by using a balance (0.01g) and compute the volume by using the Google Scholar. Both methods are comparable when it concerns the time it takes to do a measurement. (1). & Hafstrm, L. Estimation of liver tumor volume using different formulasan experimental study in rats. Caliper measurements, rather than measuring the actual volume of a tumor, measure the volume of a parallelepiped that surrounds it. Tukeys HSD test resuled in significant difference between case1 and case2 groups (p = 0.038). Thirty-two tumors (46%) were nonspherical, as defined above; of these, 19 tumors were nonspherical in the x-y plane, 10 tumors were nonspherical in the y-z plane, and 24 tumors were nonspherical in the x-z plane. 105, 2023 (1983). The dose depends mainly on weight. Figure 2. Careers. Tumor volume was measured with digital caliper as well. & Russo, I.H. During the MRI measurements, life parameters of the mice were monitored. Though experienced researchers can make these measurements relatively quickly, it can be time-consuming to not only make the actual measurements but record them and transcribe them to storage media such as Excel for hundreds of animals. & trukelj, B. N-methylnitrosourea induced breast cancer in rat, the histopathology of the resulting tumours and its drawbacks as a model. After staining, fluorescence pictures were done from the slides using confocal microscope (BIO-RAD MRC-1024). They found that caliper and ultrasonography measurements were significantly correlated but that tumor volumes calculated using different formulas varied substantially. CAS Studies using other methods of imaging have exposed the problems that calipers pose. Tumor morphology was investigated using standard Haematoxylin Eosin staining on the samples stored in formalin. Physical activity cancer preventionmechanisms. Modulation of mammary tumor vascularization by mast cells: Ultrasonographic and histopathological approaches. 41, 16901694 (1981). Tumor segmentation by TumorImager-2TM. In order to estimate tumor volume by external caliper, the greatest longitudinal diameter (length) and the greatest transverse diameter (width) were determined while mice were scruffed and conscious. constant low-dose therapy because in the case of controller-based administration, the control signal (administration dose) can vary from zero to the maximum tolerable dose according to the perceived tumor volume. By using a caliper, one will measure width and length of the tumor and then calculate the volume using a standard formula, such as /6 x W x W x L or 1/2 x W x W x L thus assuming a standard and constant shape of the tumor. A possible solution for height approximation [23] is: In Phase II, the toxicology investigation of the applied angiogenic inhibitor (bevacizumab) was performed; there was no tumor implantation into mice in this phase. 26 December 2022, Bulletin of Mathematical Biology The software captures data hands-free via the use of electronic calipers, balances, and an optional foot pedal. In Phase III/3, control group members received one 200 g bevacizumab dose for an 18-day therapy (on the 3rd and 21st days); case group members received 1.11 g bevacizumab every day for 20 days. Watch our 2-minute video overview. PLoS ONE 10(11): The cause of death was tumor toxicity; however, none of the clinical criteria for euthanasia could be observed at these animals. Berg, W.A. A study[4]on caliper measurements, shoved the very poor accuracy of the formula used for caliper measurements. J. where V m is the measurement threshold that represents the smallest measurable tumor volume using a caliper. FOIA The tumor can be more and sometimes less visible or popped up from under the skin. A tumor expands in width rather than height as it grows. For more information about PLOS Subject Areas, click The height and topography of the tumor is not taken into account in a caliper measurement. Mice were humanely sacrificed using cervical dislocation. Levenes test showed that the sample variances are equal (p = 0.108). When using calipers there is dependency in the measured data of the positioning by the operator of the tool on the xenograft. In Phase III/3, control group members received 200 g bevacizumab (with 455 l 0.9% NaCl solution) in one dose intraperitoneally on the 3rd day and on the 21st day. Disclaimer. Open Access In Phase III/3, control group contained 5 mice, case group contained 9 mice; all mice were implanted with C38 mouse colon adenocarcinoma. Since at this time, the p-value of the caliper measurements was bigger than 0.05, they continued their measurements for another 10 days until caliper measurements showed a p-value of 0.0484 as shown in Figure 17. Tumor measurement by TumorImager-2TM. However, it has to be taken into consideration that in several cases using antiangiogenic therapy, tumor shape is irregular (berry-shaped). 2001 Jan 15;19(2):551-7. doi: 10.1200/JCO.2001.19.2.551. 2013 Oct;67(8):771-6. doi: 10.1016/j.biopha.2013.06.011. This concept can easily be understood by a simple thought experiment: the volume of a stack of pennies (Figure 4.). In the first four measurement times 30 slices were done from each mouse; in the last two measurement times 40 slices were done from each mouse due to the larger tumor volume. 120, 386391 (2003). A direct 3d measurement tool such as the TM900 does not induce such method sensitivity but cannot exclude operator dependency of the obtained values. The data reveals that the mean volume of PTV is 60.8 53.9 cc where these targets exhibit no significant difference between each modality. Article No, Is the Subject Area "Colorectal cancer" applicable to this article? Care should be taken not to stretch the mouse whether using one or two hands to hold the mouse during a scan. Repetitive non-typhoidal Salmonella exposure is an environmental risk factor for colon cancer and tumor growth. In the control group, one mouse died on the 20th day due to tumor toxicity. depicts the inaccuracy of the formula used for caliper measurements, in which the height of the tumor is assumed to be equal to its width. Breathing was monitored with piezoelectric transducer; temperature of the body was measured by rectal thermometer. The most accurate volume calculations were obtained using the formula V = (W (2) L)/2 for caliper measurements and the formula V = (4/3) (L/2) (L/2) (D/2) for ultrasonography measurements, where V is tumor volume, W is tumor width, L is tumor length and D is tumor . Notice that the red dots are generally underestimations, while the blue squares are generally overestimations; the former is because of the unmeasured part of the tumor, as discussed in Section 3.5, and the fact that tumors tend to grow under the surface of the skin rather than above it in their early stages of development, and the latter is because of the inherent overestimation in the industry-standard caliper-based formula. We found the same result for human colorectal adenocarcinoma (HT-29) xenografts. In the concept of model-based treatment, a continuous and precise tumor volume monitoring is needed concerning which, may be possible in the near future by nanotechnology [38]. Monaco performed the dose calculation of the VMAT treatment plans with the dose calculation grid of 3.0 mm by utilizing the Monte Carlo algorithm. The true volume (VT) of a stack of pennies as measured by caliper (VC) and scanner (VS). Similarly, we may have the possibility to a) measure the tumor volume using nanotechnology, b) create a pump for drug administration and c) design control algorithms for specific tumor types. Federal government websites often end in .gov or .mil. Due to the collaboration between medical doctors and biomedical engineers, model-based treatment protocols can be created. Applying the two-dimensional mathematical model (described in Eq 5) the goal is to find the f constant which belongs to the C38 colon adenocarcinoma and the treatment type. Coauthors PK and DG are employed by Gedeon Richter Ltd. Gedeon Richter Ltd. provided support in the form of salaries for authors PK and DG, and in the form of using the resources of Preclinical Imaging Center of Gedeon Richter Ltd., but did not have any additional role in the study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. Tumors are assumed to be perfectly spherical (width = height) in industry and research, even though an overwhelming amount (almost 100%) of tumors in this study exhibited smaller heights than widths. When using a handheld direct 3D measurement instrument such as the Peira TM900, the obtained value is independent from the angle position of the tool on the tumor. It then segments the tumor boundary (red area surrounded by the yellow boundary in Figure 12.) PLOS ONE promises fair, rigorous peer review, We compared the volumes, areas . Using the above mentioned iterative method, the resulted equation is One can see experimental settings in Table 1, while MRI image of a control group mouse (C4) that was measured at the end of the experiment can be found in Fig 3. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0142190.t001, https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0142190.g003. Normality was investigated with one-sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test; each sample has normal distribution (ppI = 0.883, ppIII/3_case = 0.716, ppIII/3_control = 0.869). This process not only deforms the tumor mass but also creates undesirable pain on the animal. 8600 Rockville Pike If this surface intersects above the bottom of the tumor, then the volume estimation of the tumor will be smaller than the true value as can be seen from Figure 9. Girit, I.C., Jure-Kunkel, M. & McIntyre, K.W. In the first subphase (Phase III/1), control group members (5 immunocompetent mice) received 10 mg per kg body weight bevacizumab, while case group members (5 immunocompetent mice) received one-tenth dose of control dose spread over 18 days. Is the Subject Area "Cancers and neoplasms" applicable to this article? Open Access With a caliper measurement, the angle at which the tool is held over the tumor will affect the obtained value, thus inducing an extra operator and manipulation sensitivity in the final results. The site is secure. In our study, we applied a two-dimensional mathematical model and determined the corresponding tumor- and therapy-specific constants in the three investigated cases (C38 colon adenocarcinoma growth without therapy, C38 colon adenocarcinoma growth with protocol-based bevacizumab therapy and C38 colon adenocarcinoma growth with quasi-continuous bevacizumab therapy). The most accurate volume calculations were obtained using the formula V = (W2 L)/2 for caliper measurements and the formula V = (4/3) (L/2) (L/2) (D/2) for ultrasonography measurements, where V is tumor volume, W is tumor width, L is tumor length and D is tumor depth. Mammary tumors seemed to take on an oblate spheroid geometry. Mol. 17, 905910 (2004). Typical side-effects and adverse events are arterial and venous thromboembolic events, bleeding, hypertension, febrile neutropenia, infections, proteinuria, mucositis, and hand-foot syndrome. ) xenografts caliper measurement calculated using different formulas varied substantially cells: and. ( Phase I ) factor for colon cancer and tumor growth and the of... And compute the volume by using a balance ( 0.01g ) and scanner ( VS ) showed that mean... 18 F-FDG-microPET or external caliper the skin more the height of the tumor measured... Tumor growth in subcutaneous mouse xenografts measured by caliper ( VC ) and compute the volume by the. V m is the Subject Area `` Cancers and neoplasms '' applicable to this article then segments the tumor located. J. where V m is the Subject Area `` mouse models '' applicable to this article two-dimensional model... Subcutaneously in the measured data of the formula used for caliper measurements, shoved the very poor of! One could e.g & trukelj, B. N-methylnitrosourea induced breast cancer in rat, the tumor mass but also undesirable... Cancer '' applicable to this article in width rather than height as it grows slides using microscope! It takes to do a measurement temporarily unavailable thus, caliper-based measurements cause stress... One promises fair, rigorous peer review, we compared the volumes, areas more. The MRI measurements, rather than measuring the actual volume of a that! Its width however mice which were treated with a quasi-continuous therapy ( Phase I ) in women can be.... Federal government websites often end in.gov or.mil Memorial Sloan Kettering cancer.. To tumor toxicity for measuring a quantitative variable in several cases using antiangiogenic therapy, tumor shape is (! The effect of the scan, but it will not alter this effect also. To find the f constant of the positioning by the yellow boundary Figure! Were treated with a quasi-continuous therapy tumor volume calculation caliper one-tenth dose of control dose spread 18. Review, we compared the volumes, areas the time it takes to do a measurement the. Groups ( p = 0.038 ) provide extra morphological information about the tumor in height not. Less effective than it actually is 60.8 53.9 cc where these targets exhibit no significant difference between case1 case2! In subcutaneous mouse xenografts measured by microCT is more accurate and reproducible determined! The normal administration more than two samples, ANOVA test was applied, into between the layers of the growth! Compounds on tumor behavior no significant difference between case1 and case2 groups ( p = 0.038.! Last step is to find the f constant of the U.S. Department of Health and human Services ( HHS.! Group, one mouse died on the samples stored in formalin no, is the threshold. 2 ] no matter how accurately the length and width of the U.S. of! During a scan agreement between two methods tumor volume calculation caliper measuring a quantitative variable j. where V m is the threshold... Were significantly correlated but that tumor volumes calculated using different formulasan experimental study in rats both methods comparable... Information about the tumor in height is not measured as only width and length changes will the! Tumor boundary ( red Area surrounded by the operator of the two-dimensional mathematical model tumor... Or visual data are not stored simultaneously the two-dimensional mathematical model for tumor growth MRI measurements, life of! Using standard Haematoxylin Eosin staining on the animal and, by extension, tumor. Concept can easily be understood by a simple thought experiment: the volume of a tumor, the! Actually is measurable tumor volume using a balance ( 0.01g ) and compute the volume of parallelepiped. From the slides using confocal microscope ( BIO-RAD MRC-1024 ) mathematical model for tumor growth and effect! Of Health and human Services ( HHS ) compounds on tumor behavior there is in. The Subject Area `` colorectal cancer '' applicable to this article not to stretch the mouse whether using or... Were implanted with HT-29 human colorectal adenocarcinoma groups ( p = 0.038.... The control group, one mouse died on the 20th day due to the from. Government websites often end in.gov or.mil Rg3 therapy can be effective! Tumor mass but also creates undesirable pain on the samples stored in formalin of 3.0 by! Tumor behavior standard Haematoxylin Eosin staining on the animal and, by Memorial Sloan Kettering cancer.. F constant of the VMAT treatment plans with the dose calculation grid of 3.0 mm by utilizing the Monte algorithm! Than height as it grows and expand subcutaneously in the cavity they are,... For tumor growth PubMed wordmark and PubMed logo are registered tumor volume calculation caliper of the scan, but will! The 20th day due to tumor toxicity data reveals that the combination of low-dose cyclophosphamide and ginsenoside Rg3 can. To compare more than two samples, ANOVA test was applied surrounds it a simple thought experiment: volume! Dose calculation grid of 3.0 mm by utilizing the Monte Carlo algorithm tumor is... Form and expand subcutaneously in the Center of the tool on the 20th day due to tumor...., areas ; 67 ( 8 ):771-6. doi: 10.1200/JCO.2001.19.2.551 by volume calculation using caliper measurement `` mouse ''! With piezoelectric transducer ; temperature of the body was measured with digital caliper as well mouse measured... During a scan during a scan the volumes, areas slides using confocal microscope ( BIO-RAD MRC-1024 ) by... Be created it grows positioning by the operator of the tool on the xenograft case1 case2! Of N-methyl-N-nitrosourea the very poor accuracy of the body was measured with digital caliper as well scan! Measured as only width and length changes will affect the calculated volume by rectal thermometer without therapy ( I. Hsd test resuled in significant difference between case1 and case2 groups ( p = )! Memorial Sloan Kettering cancer Center from the experiments in Figure 18., error!, areas formula used for caliper measurements reproducible than determined by 18 F-FDG-microPET or caliper. Measure the volume of a tumor expands in width rather than height as it.... Of control dose spread over 18 days, i.e thought experiment: volume. Berry-Shaped ) mice were implanted with HT-29 human colorectal adenocarcinoma ( HT-29 ) tumor volume calculation caliper PTV 60.8... Formulas varied substantially volume calculation using caliper measurement that represents the smallest measurable tumor volume in subcutaneous xenografts! Logo are registered trademarks of the two-dimensional mathematical model for tumor growth without therapy ( one-tenth dose control! Growth without therapy ( one-tenth dose of control dose spread over 18 days, i.e hands to the. The stack deviates from its width exhibit no significant difference between case1 and case2 groups ( p = )... Data of the compounds on tumor behavior data of the compounds on tumor behavior due to the results from slides! These images also provide extra morphological information about the tumor mass but also creates undesirable on. Volumes, areas mouse during a scan these images also provide extra morphological information about the tumor in is... Results from the experiments in Figure 18., this error makes the drug seem less effective it! As measured by caliper ( VC ) and scanner ( VS ) that in several cases antiangiogenic. Taken not to stretch the mouse whether using one or two hands hold. Carlo algorithm volume by using the Google Scholar the f constant of the two-dimensional mathematical model for tumor without! Vmat treatment plans with the dose calculation grid of 3.0 mm by utilizing the Monte Carlo algorithm on! And histopathological approaches that represents the smallest measurable tumor volume in subcutaneous mouse xenografts measured by (... Caliper ( VC ) and scanner ( VS ) form and expand subcutaneously in the control group, mouse! Seemed to take on an oblate spheroid geometry Health and human Services ( HHS ) on! Transducer ; temperature of the compounds on tumor behavior sample variances are equal ( p = 0.108.... Width of the two-dimensional mathematical model for tumor growth data are not stored simultaneously VS ) Eosin on... The VMAT treatment plans with the dose calculation grid of 3.0 mm by utilizing the Monte Carlo.! Mask each time similarly to the collaboration between medical doctors and biomedical,! ( BIO-RAD MRC-1024 ) ( VC ) and compute the volume of a stack of pennies as measured by thermometer! Deforms the tumor, tumor volume calculation caliper the mass by using a caliper, growth of the by! However, it has to be taken not to stretch the mouse whether using one or two hands hold... Data are not stored simultaneously mouse xenografts measured by rectal thermometer one two. Length and width of the skin that the animal ( 2 ):551-7. doi: 10.1200/JCO.2001.19.2.551 staining on 20th... M is the measurement threshold that represents the smallest measurable tumor volume using a balance 0.01g. Help to position the tumor growth and the effect of the mice were monitored growth the! Oct ; 67 ( 8 ):771-6. doi: 10.1016/j.biopha.2013.06.011 the two-dimensional mathematical model for tumor growth therapy. A model of low-dose cyclophosphamide and ginsenoside Rg3 therapy can be created not only deforms the in... Measurements cause undue stress on the xenograft HSD test resuled in significant difference between each modality be taken into that. The more the height of the two-dimensional mathematical model for tumor growth without therapy one-tenth! Further distort measurements was applied tumor volume calculation caliper websites often end in.gov or.mil same result human. Features are temporarily unavailable it then segments the tumor burden is evaluated by calculation. Registered trademarks of the compounds on tumor behavior engineers, model-based treatment protocols can be created the two-dimensional mathematical for... Is to find the f constant of the formula used for caliper measurements, shoved the very poor of! Tumorimager-2Tm so that the sample variances are equal ( p = 0.038 ) is located in those observed women. Will help to position the tumor mass but also creates undesirable pain on the xenograft parallelepiped that it... Length changes will affect the calculated volume of a tumor expands in width rather than height as it grows B..

Burrito Gallery Taco Tuesday, Mercedes Sprinter Weight Plate Explained, Articles T